Taxing the rich. Income vs wealth
Part 3: Does HMRC Calling You Wealthy, Mean You’re Rich?
In this part we challenge the assumptions underpinning the debate about “taxing the rich” and considers why existing tax contributions, accumulated wealth and wider financial circumstances should inform discussions about who should pay more tax.
This distinction also matters when considering whether people on higher incomes should be paying more tax.

If somebody wants to make the case that people earning £150,000 or £200,000 should pay more Income Tax, make that argument.
There is a legitimate debate to have about the distribution of taxation. But acknowledge what they already pay. For example, in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, somebody earning £150,000 in ordinary employment in England, Wales or Northern Ireland would pay approximately £53,703 in Income Tax and £5,011 in employee National Insurance, based on the simplified assumptions used in these articles.
That does not prove they are overtaxed. It does not prove they are undertaxed either. It tells us what it tells us. They have a high income and they make a substantial contribution through taxation associated with that income. Whether they are wealthy requires more information. Whether they are “rich” requires us first to decide what we mean by the word.
That is why I think some of the political discussion around “taxing the rich” becomes unnecessarily muddled. We start with a slogan, attach an income threshold to it and then behave as though the difficult work has been done. It has not. If the concern is high employment income, call it high employment income. If the concern is accumulated wealth, measure wealth. If the concern is somebody’s overall capacity to contribute more towards public finances, then we need a more sophisticated discussion about their economic resources and the taxes they already bear. Otherwise, we risk building tax policy around a label rather than the thing the label is supposed to describe.
There is a practical HMRC point as well. Being within HMRC’s wealthy population does not mean HMRC has decided somebody has done anything wrong. HMRC’s current Wealthy and Mid-sized Business Compliance Directorate says its aim is to increase voluntary compliance while challenging those who break the rules. The classification tells us something about how HMRC organises and targets its compliance work. It is not a finding of non-compliance. (GOV.UK) That distinction matters to taxpayers and advisers because the word “wealthy” can sound rather more dramatic than the administrative machinery underneath it.
My own view is that HMRC should make that distinction clearer whenever it publishes the definition. I also think fixed monetary thresholds of this importance deserve periodic, transparent review. That does not mean they must automatically rise. It means somebody should occasionally ask whether the boundary still identifies the population it was intended to identify, and explain the answer. The wider public debate could benefit from exactly the same discipline.
I am not arguing that £200,000 is an ordinary salary. It plainly is not. I am not arguing that £2 million of assets is insignificant. It plainly is not that either. And I am certainly not suggesting that somebody earning £150,000 should be invited to open a crowdfunding page because HMRC has left them with only £91,000 or so after Income Tax and employee National Insurance. That would be absurd.
I am making a narrower point, but I think it is an important one. Income is not wealth. Tax paid is not wealth. Take-home pay is not wealth. HMRC’s customer-segmentation definition is not, by itself, a universal definition of what it means to be rich.
Once we accept that, the argument becomes much more interesting. Perhaps the real question is not whether somebody earning £150,000 pays enough tax. Perhaps it is whether we have become so accustomed to using the word “rich” that we have stopped asking what we actually mean by it. Because before deciding who should pay more, it would be useful to know who we are talking about.
The tax system is complicated enough without making the English language liable for additional duties as well.
(Disclaimer: This article provides general commentary and information only and should not be treated as tax advice. You should seek advice from a suitably qualified professional to review your case and advise you on your own circumstances where appropriate.)



