Does HMRC Calling You Wealthy, Mean You’re Rich?
This three-part series explores the difference between earning a high income and being wealthy, using HMRC's definition of wealth to examine what we really mean by “taxing the rich”.
Part 1: High income, tax contributions and wealth. Are they the same thing?
Examines the taxes people already pay at different income levels and explains why neither a high salary nor substantial disposable income necessarily means someone is wealthy.
Part 2: HMRC's wealthy customer population. What does the label really mean?
Explores how and why HMRC classifies individuals as wealthy for tax administration and compliance purposes, how its qualifying thresholds have evolved and whether they remain appropriate.
Part 3: Taxing the rich. Income vs wealth
Challenges the assumptions underpinning the debate about “taxing the rich” and considers why existing tax contributions, accumulated wealth and wider financial circumstances should inform discussions about who should pay more tax.
______________________________________________________________
Does HMRC Calling You Wealthy, Mean You’re Rich?
Part 1: High income, tax contributions and wealth. Are they the same thing?
Examining how much tax people already contribute, the relationship between income and accumulated wealth, and why earning a high salary does not necessarily mean someone is rich.

We regularly see a familiar argument about “taxing the rich” and a recent post compared somebody earning £150,000 with somebody earning £25,000 and pointed out that the higher earner pays substantially more Income Tax.
While I could see the point being made, before asking somebody to contribute more, it seems reasonable to understand how much they are already contributing. And the more I looked at the conclusion in the post, the more I thought the argument was starting in the wrong place.
Before we decide whether the rich are paying enough tax, perhaps we ought to answer a more basic question. Who exactly are the rich? That sounds simple until you try to define it. Is somebody rich because they earn a high salary? Because they own valuable assets? Because they have enough capital to stop working? Or because HMRC has placed them in a customer group carrying the word “wealthy”? These are not necessarily the same thing. This is noteworthy because HMRC has its own criteria for identifying wealthy taxpayers.
You can read on HMRC's definition of its wealthy customer population and what those thresholds actually mean with this link.
There is also a problem with looking only at Income Tax. If we are going to use somebody’s tax contribution as part of the argument, we should at least acknowledge that Income Tax is not the only compulsory deduction associated with their salary. For the 2026 to 2027 tax year, somebody earning £25,000, assuming ordinary employment income and the rates applying in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, would pay approximately £2,486 in Income Tax.
Somebody earning £150,000 would pay approximately £53,703. The second figure is slightly higher than the £53,460 shown in the LinkedIn graphic, principally because somebody earning £150,000 has lost their Personal Allowance entirely and part of their income falls within the 45% additional rate. Scottish Income Tax rates are different, so the calculation would differ for a Scottish taxpayer.
But that still does not show the full deduction from salary. Take a standard category A employee who is paid evenly through the year. For 2026 to 2027, employee Class 1 National Insurance is generally charged at 8% between the primary threshold and upper earnings limit, then at 2% above the upper earnings limit. On those simplified assumptions, the £25,000 employee would pay about £994 in employee National Insurance. The £150,000 employee would pay about £5,011.
Put Income Tax and employee National Insurance together and our two employees have immediate statutory deductions of roughly £3,480 and £58,714 respectively. That changes the comparison slightly. It does not change the basic point. The higher earner is contributing considerably more through the taxes and National Insurance associated with their employment income.
And even then, the tax system has not finished with them. Once the remaining salary reaches the bank account, people may encounter VAT when they spend it. The standard VAT rate is 20% on most goods and services, although other supplies are reduced-rated, zero-rated or exempt. People responsible for a property may have Council Tax to pay, with domestic rates applying instead in Northern Ireland. Buy certain types of insurance and the premium may include Insurance Premium Tax, normally at 12% for most taxable insurance and 20% in specified circumstances. There are then other taxes and duties depending upon what somebody owns, buys or does. Tax has an unfortunate habit of not regarding the arrival of your net salary as the end of its working day.
I would not pretend that we can simply add all of those taxes together and produce one neat percentage showing somebody’s “true tax burden”. We cannot. VAT depends on what somebody buys. Council Tax depends on the property and local authority. Insurance Premium Tax depends on the insurance purchased. Other taxes depend on individual circumstances.
Not every person pays every tax, and not every payslip deduction is itself taxation. Student loan repayments, for example, can reduce take-home pay substantially but are conceptually different again. That distinction matters because the purpose of broadening the tax calculation is not to prove that somebody earning £150,000 cannot possibly be rich. That would be just as simplistic as assuming that they must be rich.
The point is that a salary figure tells us less about somebody’s actual financial position than we sometimes pretend it does. A person earning £150,000 may have considerably less than £150,000 available to spend. That is hardly a revelation. But, more importantly, even knowing their disposable income still does not tell us how wealthy they are. This is where I think the language starts causing the problem. High income and wealth are connected. Somebody earning a significant income has a greater opportunity to accumulate assets than somebody earning considerably less, all other things being equal. But an opportunity to accumulate wealth is not the same thing as having accumulated it.
Imagine somebody who has only recently started earning £200,000. They have a substantial mortgage, relatively little accumulated capital and perhaps twenty or thirty years of employment ahead of them. Their income is unquestionably high. Their financial position may be comfortable. But most of their economic security still depends upon continuing to work and receiving the next salary payment. Now consider somebody earning £60,000 who owns substantial investments and property outright, has a large pension fund and could stop working without materially altering their standard of living. Which of those people is wealthier? That is not a trick question. It simply exposes the problem with treating annual income as though it were a balance sheet.
The Office for National Statistics approaches wealth very differently. Its current methodology measures household wealth through components including net financial wealth, net property wealth, private pension wealth and physical wealth. Mortgage debt is deducted when calculating net property wealth, while relevant financial liabilities reduce financial wealth. Wealth, in that sense, concerns resources accumulated over time rather than simply what somebody earned this year.
This is why I think we need to be more careful when we move between the words “high earner”, “wealthy” and “rich”. It also raises a wider question about who should be considered rich and how that influences taxation.
(Disclaimer: This article provides general commentary and information only and should not be treated as tax advice. You should seek advice from a suitably qualified professional to review your case and advise you on your own circumstances where appropriate.)



