top of page

Questioning HMRC decisions: Why the right approach matters

bducran
2 hours ago
6 min read

Part 2: Why specialist tax advice matters



What HMRC publishes, and what experience adds 


When an HMRC decision is disputed, identifying why it may be incorrect is only part of the challenge. Knowing how to bring the issue to HMRC's attention, and which approach is appropriate at that stage, can be equally important. Understanding how the department's procedures operate in practice makes a significant difference in the outcome you are seeking. 


HMRC publishes an extensive collection of technical and operational manuals on GOV.UK. These explain how the department interprets legislation, approaches particular tax issues and expects its officers to carry out various duties. 


This information is publicly available, and rightly so. Publication provides an important measure of transparency, enabling taxpayers and professional advisers to understand HMRC's published approach and question its application where necessary. 

However, having access to HMRC's published guidance is not necessarily the same as understanding how its procedures operate in practice or how they influence the handling of a particular case. 


Although HMRC publishes substantial amounts of technical and operational information, not all its internal guidance is made available to the public.  Some material is withheld under exemptions provided by the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Certain HMRC manuals expressly identify passages withheld under the Act, including the Compliance Handbook at CH21520. 


There may be legitimate reasons for withholding such information. The relevant point is that the published manuals do not necessarily provide a complete account of the internal guidance available to HMRC officers. 


HMRC also acknowledges that its published manuals are not comprehensive and do not provide a definitive answer in every case. 


That does not mean HMRC operates under a different set of tax laws from everyone else. Legislation and binding legal authority determine the legal position. HMRC's internal guidance cannot override those requirements. 


But understanding how the department interprets and administers the law, how its officers obtain technical assistance and how decisions are considered or reviewed can provide a valuable additional perspective. 


During my HMRC career, part of my role involved helping caseworkers and their managers understand how legislation, technical guidance and operational procedures should be applied to the facts of individual cases. 


That work went beyond identifying the relevant guidance. It involved examining whether the information and evidence supported the approach being taken and determining what further action, if any, was necessary to establish the correct position. 


There is an important practical difference between reading a procedure and having first-hand experience of how it operates when a difficult case needs to be resolved. To be clear, the value of former HMRC experience does not mean privileged access to the department, nor does it provide continuing access to confidential information. The real value lies in the knowledge and professional judgement developed through working within the organisation and understanding how its procedures operate in practice. 


After all, HMRC's manuals are extensive, but even the most detailed manual cannot necessarily explain why a particular case or enquiry has spent the last six months going round in circles. 


Understanding the written procedures is important. Knowing how they operate in practice and applying that understanding to the circumstances of a particular case, is where additional experience can make a meaningful difference. 


Recognising a mistake is one thing. Knowing how to put it right is another 


These days there is no shortage of commentary about HMRC's standards of service, particularly when a decision appears questionable. 


I do not propose to debate the merits of every criticism. Similar concerns have been raised throughout my career, both within HMRC and since moving into private practice. Given the scale of HMRC's responsibilities and the millions of taxpayers it deals with, difficulties will inevitably arise, particularly as systems, procedures and circumstances change. That does not excuse mistakes, nor does it mean every criticism is justified. 


Some will suggest that a caseworker lacked experience, misunderstood the facts or did not receive sufficient technical support. There may be some truth in those explanations, but speculating about why a decision was reached does not establish whether it was justified, nor does it tell the taxpayer how best to address it. 


So, recognising and understanding why something may have gone wrong is not necessarily the same as knowing how to put it right. 


This is where specialist experience and professional judgement can make a difference. Two cases involving essentially the same tax issue may require quite different approaches. The evidence available and the stage reached in HMRC's procedures can influence the appropriate course of action. It may also matter which officer, or team has responsibility for the issue and whether the decision can be reconsidered directly or requires further technical or managerial attention. 


One case may be resolved through a carefully reasoned letter. Another may require action through formal review or appeal procedures. 


The distinction is important. Knowing the substantive tax position is essential, but it does not necessarily determine the most effective way of progressing the matter. Understanding where a case stands within HMRC's procedures, and what options remain available, may be just as important. 


In my experience, relatively small differences in how and when a matter is addressed can make a considerable difference. Recognising the appropriate point to raise an issue, or identifying that further technical consideration is needed, may avoid unnecessary correspondence and expense. 


That is not about finding fault with individual caseworkers. It is about understanding the circumstances of the case and applying the right professional judgement at the right time. 

I have seen the practical value of this approach in our own work. 


On more than one occasion, clients have approached us after receiving an HMRC decision they believed was incorrect. Having examined the position, we wrote to HMRC explaining why the decision should be reconsidered. In those instances, one letter in each case was sufficient for HMRC to reconsider the matter and accept the client's position. The issues were resolved without needing to proceed to a statutory review, Alternative Dispute Resolution or proceedings before the tax tribunal. That is a useful illustration of what an appropriately focused professional intervention can achieve. 


It would be wrong to suggest that every disagreement can be resolved through a single letter. Some matters require substantial investigation, while others involve genuine differences in legal interpretation that may need to be determined through formal proceedings. 


There is also an important procedural safeguard. Where HMRC has issued an appealable decision, correspondence requesting reconsideration must not be assumed to extend the statutory appeal deadline or, without checking its content and circumstances, to constitute a valid appeal. Those rights must be protected even where discussions with HMRC are continuing. 


Nevertheless, the experience demonstrates something important. The value of specialist advice is not necessarily reflected in the volume of work produced or the amount of correspondence exchanged. 


In the cases I have described, the important measure was not the length of the letters we wrote. It was that HMRC reconsidered the decisions and the matters were resolved without further formal escalation. 


After all, it is one thing to identify what HMRC may have got wrong. It is quite another to know how to demonstrate it, what needs to happen next and how best to get it put right. 


The hidden commercial cost of unresolved tax issues 


When businesses consider the financial consequences of an HMRC enquiry or a difficult tax matter, their attention naturally turns to the potential tax liability and professional fees. Interest or that penalties may also be involved. 


Those costs matter, but they may not represent the full commercial impact. 


Consider a business owner who spends several hours each week reviewing correspondence, discussing an enquiry with advisers and locating information requested by HMRC. The time involved may appear manageable when considered one week at a time. Over several months, however, the cumulative effect can become substantial. 


For smaller businesses, where directors often have several operational responsibilities, that diversion can be particularly significant. Commercial decisions may be delayed, and opportunities receive less attention while the business attempts to deal with the continuing uncertainty. 


An HMRC enquiry rarely appears in a company's business plan under the heading of "growth opportunities", yet it can acquire a remarkable ability to occupy the time and efforts of the people responsible for delivering that growth. 


There is a significant difference between the time reasonably required to investigate a difficult matter and time consumed because the enquiry has lost its direction.  That does not mean every case should be challenged or pursued regardless of cost. Sometimes the evidence establishes that HMRC has a legitimate point and further disagreement would serve little useful purpose. 


Sometimes, knowing what not to pursue can be just as valuable as knowing when to stand your ground. 


The financial consequences of unnecessary delay are not always visible in the tax calculation. They may appear elsewhere in the business, through postponed investment decisions or opportunities that were never pursued. 

This is why the commercial value of specialist advice should be considered more broadly than the amount of tax eventually payable. 


Contact C&B Partners Limited to discuss your circumstances. 

 

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about the potential value of specialist tax advice. It does not constitute advice on any particular matter or guarantee any outcome from HMRC. The appropriate action depends on individual circumstances, applicable legislation and relevant procedural requirements. Businesses should obtain professional advice appropriate to their circumstances and observe any applicable statutory deadlines. 

 
 
bottom of page